How do you choose what to read next when you can't decide?
The short answer: Stop debating and use a simple rule. Pick by mood, by the next book in a series you already started, by the shortest book on the pile, by the book that has waited longest, or let chance choose. If your books live in Dog-Ear, the Pick My Next Book wheel does the choosing for you from your own shelves, your wish list, or a list of new ideas.
You have a shelf full of books you own, and you stand there and read spines for ten minutes. Then you open your phone instead. Nothing is wrong with you. Choosing gets harder the more good options you have, and most readers go through it. Readers in forum threads about this answer in the same few ways: mood, chance, a plan, a deadline, or cutting the list down. This guide turns those into rules you can use tonight.
Why is picking the next book harder than reading it?
Reading a book only needs you to start. Choosing needs you to compare a dozen books against how you feel right now, and every book you skip feels like a small loss. A long list also makes each book look like a promise you have not kept yet.
If the real problem is that you do not want to read anything at all, that is a different thing, and the guide to reading slump causes and fixes will help more. This post is for the days when you want to read and cannot pick. If a book you picked is not working out, how to track books you did not finish shows what to do with it.
What are the simple ways to choose?
Pick one rule and use it for a month. You can change it later.
- Mood. Ask what you feel like: something fast, something cozy, something that will make you cry. Take the first book on your shelf that fits the answer. Do not look for a better one.
- The next book in a series. If you are partway through a series, read the next one. It is the easiest rule, because the choice was already made when you started book one.
- The shortest book on the pile. A short book gets you a finished book and a good feeling quickly, which makes the next choice easier.
- The book that has waited longest. Take the one you have owned the longest. Read fifty pages. If it is not working, let it go.
- Chance. Number your options, write titles on slips of paper, or use a dice roll. Some readers choose a book blind this way. If you feel a little disappointed by the result, that tells you which book you wanted instead, so read that one.
- A deadline. A library due date, a book club meeting or a friend waiting to borrow something settles the question for you.
Should you read a series in order?
Mostly, yes. Later books in a series usually spoil or assume what happened earlier, so jumping to book three can ruin book one. If you own several books of a series, the one to pick is the lowest numbered book you have not read. You can see which books you own and which are missing in how to track book series you own.
How does the Pick My Next Book wheel in Dog-Ear work?
Dog-Ear has a page called Pick My Next Book. You find it in the More menu. It does the "pick one and spin" idea for you.
- Open Pick My Next Book.
- Under Pick from, choose From my shelves (books you own and have not read), From my wish list (to help you decide what to buy next), or Find me something new (book ideas by genre).
- Under In the mood for, choose one of: Surprise Me, Continue a Series, Finish a Series, Start a New Series, Fantasy, Romance, Dark Romance, Shorter Read, Longer Read or Reread.
- Tap Spin. One book comes up.
A few details are worth knowing.
- A series only offers its next book. Whatever mood you choose, a book that belongs to a series only comes up if it is the lowest numbered unread book of that series that you own. It will not offer book four while you still have book three waiting, and it will not offer another book of a series while you are partway through one.
- Shorter Read and Longer Read need page counts. Shorter means 350 pages or fewer and Longer means 450 pages or more. If your books have no page counts, the wheel will tell you and offers to look them up. Our guide to updating a page count shows where.
- Cookbooks, reference books, journals and coloring books stay out of the wheel. They are not meant to be read cover to cover.
- From my wish list leaves out Finish a Series and Reread, since those need books you own.
- If nothing fits a mood, it says so and you can try another mood.
It is a small tool, and it will not know your taste better than you do. What it takes away is the ten minutes of staring.
Pick My Next Book after a spin, in a sample library.
What if the pick feels wrong?
Spin again, or read the first chapter. Giving a pick a chance for fifty pages costs you very little, and putting a book down is allowed. A book you set aside is not a failure. It just means the pile gets shorter and the next spin has fewer books to choose from.
When is this not for you?
If you read from a short list, or you already have a system that works, you do not need a wheel. A jar of slips of paper works as well, and so does a calendar of planned reads. Pick whatever you will actually use.
Try it on your own shelf
If you are curious, Dog-Ear is at dogearreads.com. The tips above work with a jar and some slips of paper too.
Start freeQuestions
How do I choose my next book when I have too many to pick from?
Use one rule for a month: mood, the next book in a series, the shortest book, the book that has waited longest, or a random pick. A rule you do not have to think about is the fix.
Is it okay to choose books by mood?
Yes. A book you are in the mood for is more likely to be finished than a book you feel you should read. Many readers choose this way.
Should I finish a series before starting a new one?
You do not have to. Many readers keep one series going at a time and a standalone book alongside it. Reading a series in order matters more than finishing it fast.
How does Pick My Next Book choose?
It picks one book at random from the books that match the place you chose and the mood you chose, and it only offers the next unread book of any series.
Can I use it for books I have not bought yet?
Yes. Choose From my wish list to pick from books on your wish list, or Find me something new to get ideas by genre.
Related: Reading slump causes and fixes, How to track book series you own, How to fix a book's page count in Dog-Ear.