Reading app subscription or one time payment: what should a book tracker cost?
The short answer: a reading app is worth a subscription if you use its paid extras every week, and worth a one time payment if you want your reading history to stay put for years. The fair way to compare is the cost over 5 years: the yearly plans checked here cost $149.95 to $249.95 over that time, while Dog-Ear is one payment of $29.
A book tracker rarely costs much in any single month, which is exactly why the price is easy to ignore. But your reading history is something you keep for years, so the number that matters is the total, not the monthly figure. This post lays out what several book tracking apps charge, with the date and source for every price, then gives you a simple way to judge value for yourself. It is not a ranking. Each app suits a different reader.
What book tracking apps charge, checked October 16, 2026
| App | Free version | Paid plan |
|---|---|---|
| Goodreads | Free, with ads | No paid plan listed |
| Hardcover | Free, with unlimited books in your library | Supporter: $4.99 a month or $49.99 a year |
| The StoryGraph | Free core app | Plus: $49.99 a year, with a 30 day free trial |
| Bookly | Free to download and use | Pro: $4.99 a month, $19.99 for 6 months or $29.99 a year, after a 7 day trial |
| Libib | Basic: free, up to 5,000 items and 100 collections | Pro: $9 a month or $99 a year, up to 100,000 items |
| Dog-Ear | Free for up to 50 books, wish list included | Full version: one payment of $29, no subscription |
US dollars, fetched October 16, 2026. Sources: Goodreads App Store listing, Hardcover pricing, StoryGraph Plus, Bookly App Store listing, Libib pricing. Prices change and differ by country, so check before you buy.
The cost over 5 years
This table multiplies the yearly price by five. It uses only the prices above, and only the yearly plans.
| App and plan | Per year | 5 years |
|---|---|---|
| Goodreads | Free | Free |
| Hardcover free plan | Free | Free |
| Bookly Pro | $29.99 | $149.95 |
| Hardcover Supporter | $49.99 | $249.95 |
| The StoryGraph Plus | $49.99 | $249.95 |
| Libib Pro | $99 | $495 |
| Dog-Ear full version | One payment, $29 | One payment |
Libib Pro only matters if you need more than 5,000 items, since the free Basic plan holds that many. Monthly plans cost more per year than yearly ones, so these are the lower totals. This table shows cost only, not which app is better for you.
How to judge value, whatever app you pick
- Count the years. Multiply the yearly price by the number of years you expect to keep reading. If the app holds your history, that is probably five years or more.
- Name the extra. Write down the one paid feature you would use every week. If you cannot, the free version may be enough.
- Check the free limit. Free versions limit different things: the number of books, certain stats, or how you can add books. Find yours before you start entering data.
- Ask about leaving. Before you build a library, check that you can export it. Moving later is easier when your list is portable.
- Match the model to your habits. If you change apps every year, a monthly plan is flexible. If you stay put, one payment tends to cost less over time.
Who each option suits
- Goodreads suits readers who want the biggest community and catalog and do not mind ads.
- Hardcover suits readers who want an unlimited free library, with the paid plan as optional support.
- The StoryGraph suits readers who love stats: Plus adds custom charts, extra stats filters and comparisons.
- Bookly suits readers who want a reading timer and goals, at the lowest yearly price in the table above.
- Libib suits anyone cataloging a big home library, because its free plan holds 5,000 items.
- Dog-Ear suits readers who own physical books and want one private place that never bills them again.
What one payment of $29 gets you in Dog-Ear
Dog-Ear's free plan holds up to 50 books, with your wish list counting toward that, so you can try it properly before paying anything. The full version is one payment, lifetime, with no subscription. It removes the 50 book limit and adds talking instead of typing and 100+ journal stickers. Scanning, importing from Goodreads or StoryGraph, series tracking, the wish list, journal pages and stats are all in the free plan too. Here is exactly what the free plan includes, and here is a 3 year look at the subscription apps.
A library screen in a sample library, on the full version.
The home screen with shelf totals, in the same sample library.
When Dog-Ear is not the right pick
- You want a social feed. Dog-Ear is a private journal, so it has no public feed or friends list. Goodreads and Hardcover are built around other readers.
- You want a reading timer. Bookly is built around timing your reading.
- You have thousands of items to catalog. Libib's free plan holds 5,000 items. Dog-Ear's free plan holds 50 books.
- You only read a few books a year. A free tracker, or Dog-Ear's free plan, may be all you ever need.
Dog-Ear works in your phone's browser and on your home screen, so if you want a store download only, check that before you choose.
Pay once, keep your shelf
Start free with up to 50 books, then upgrade only if you need more. $29, one time, no subscription.
Get Dog-Ear for $29Questions
Is a reading app better as a subscription or a one time payment?
Neither is better for everyone. A subscription suits you if you use the extras every week or want to switch apps often. One payment suits you if you want your reading history in one place for years without a bill. Compare the cost over 5 years, not the monthly price.
How much do book tracking apps cost?
On October 16, 2026, Goodreads was free with ads, Hardcover's Supporter plan was $49.99 a year, The StoryGraph Plus was $49.99 a year, and Bookly Pro was $29.99 a year. Libib's free plan holds 5,000 items and its Pro plan is $99 a year. Prices change, so check each app's own page.
How much does a book tracker cost over 5 years?
On the yearly plans checked here, $49.99 a year comes to $249.95 over 5 years, and Bookly Pro at $29.99 a year comes to $149.95. Dog-Ear is one payment, with no renewal in year 2 or year 5.
Do I need to pay for a book tracker at all?
No. Goodreads and Hardcover are free to use, and most paid apps have a free version. Pay only if a specific paid feature, a bigger limit or a calmer, private space is worth it to you.
What does Dog-Ear cost?
Dog-Ear is free for up to 50 books, with your wish list counting toward that. The full version is one payment of $29, with no subscription. It removes the 50 book limit and adds talking instead of typing and 100+ journal stickers.
Related: Book tracker apps with no subscription, A free book tracker for your first 50 books, How to move from Goodreads to Dog-Ear, How to back up your reading list.